Adam Platt is the second major critic to file a full review of the recently rejiggered Eleven Madison Park (Cheshes snuck in before the end of the year with a five star rave in Time Out New York). Like Pete Wells, Platt noticed some stumbles in the execution of the original New York-themed menu, but he finds that chef Daniel Humm has smoothed out the wrinkles since the fall:
Link to Article: 
http://ny.eater.com/archives/2013/01/platt_awards_four_stars_to_the_new_eleven_madison_park.php
Article Source: 
NY Eater