Taste the Fine Dining in New York!

Key West Cafe

Key West Cafe

*Promotions listed are subject to change without notice and based on availability. We make no guarantee that the promotions listed are available.

Key West Cafe Summary

Key West Cafe Information

Restaurant Quick Facts

  • Key West Cafe is located on site at the charming Hotel Newton NYC.

Restaurant Info

Upper West Side

2528 Broadway
New York, NY 10025
View Map

Nearest Transit:
96th St (1, 2, 3)

Hours of Operation:
Mon.-Sun. 6am-1am

NYCTourist Travel Info

User Average Review


Based on 0 reviews

Rating Distribution

0.0% recommended it

Key West Cafe Reviews

There are currently no reviews!
Be the first to write a review!

Restaurant Hotel

Located among the quaint brownstones of Manhattan's posh Upper West Side, just three blocks from Central Park, Hotel Newton offers guests handsome guest rooms, warm service, and easy access to all of New York's most popular attractions.

*Some images shown above are not actual photos from the restaurant, but category representations. Visit the restaurant's web site for actual photos.

NYCTourist Travel Info

Find Nearby Hotels

no results
american Cuisine

Key West Cafe

Do you agree? Write your own review!

Comfort Food and Affordability at Key West Cafe

Located in


Upper West Side

Price Range:

NYCTourist Travel Info

Features: Key West Cafe NYC features a diverse menu of Italian, American, and Greek food in a classic diner setting.

Why We Dine: Located on site at the lovely Hotel Newton, Key West Cafe offers Italian, American, and Greek comfort food in a bright and cheerful setting.

  • Decor: With its cool, crisp lines, white tile floor, and pink and aqua booths, Key West Cafe NYC recalls the delightful American diners of the Fifties and Sixties.
  • Affordability: With sandwiches running just a touch over ten dollars, the charming Key West Cafe NYC is as much a bargain as it is a delight.
  • Convenience: An excellent choice for early risers and night hawks alike, Key West Cafe is open daily from 6am-1am.

Inside Knowledge: Frank Tsiamtsouris and Fotis Hilas, the brothers-in-law behind Key West Cafe NYC, run four other excellent New York restaurants, including Metro, City, and Manhattan diners uptown.

We Recommend:

  • Norwegian Salmon Sandwich: This delicious sandwich features fresh Norwegian salmon on seven-grain bread with lemon dill caper mayonnaise, sliced cucumbers, and fresh arugula served with mesclun greens. At $14.95, it can't be beat.
  • Key West Mediterranean Burger: Try this burger and you'll see why many of Key West Cafe NY's patrons have been regulars for over ten years.
  • Dessert: A slice of dense cheesecake, delicious strawberry shortcake, or decadent chocolate mousse cake will make a perfect end to any meal.

Restaurant Amenities